Particle sizing methods for the detection of protein aggregates in biopharmaceuticals

Papers of special note have been highlighted as: • of interest; •• of considerable interest

References

• 1 Patrick GL. An Introduction to Medicinal Chemistry. Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK (2013).
  Google Scholar
• 2 Roberts CJ. Protein aggregation and its impact on product quality. Curr. Opin. Biotechnol. 30, 211–217 (2014).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 3 Tutar Y, Özgür A, Tutar L. Role of protein aggregation. In: Neurodegenerative Diseases. Kishore U (Ed.). InTech Publishing, Croatia (2013).
  Google Scholar
• 4 Hong H. Toward understanding driving forces in membrane protein folding. Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 564, 297–313 (2014).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 5 Tyedmers J, Mogk A, Bukau B. Cellular strategies for controlling protein aggregation. Nat. Rev. Mol. Cell Biol. 11(11), 777–788 (2010).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 6 Takalo M, Salminen A, Soininen H, Hiltunen M, Haapasalo A. Protein aggregation and degradation mechanisms in neurodegenerative diseases. Am. J. Neurodegener. Dis. 2(1), 1–14 (2013).
  MedlineGoogle Scholar
• 7 Carter PJ. Introduction to current and future protein therapeutics: a protein engineering perspective. Exp. Cell Res. 317(9), 1261–1269 (2011).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 8 Wang W, Roberts CJ (Eds). Aggregation of Therapeutic Proteins. John Wiley & Sons, Inc., Hoboken, NJ, USA (2010).
  Google Scholar
• 9 Walsh G. Biopharmaceutical benchmarks 2014. Nat. Biotech. 32, 992–1000 (2014).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 10 Leader B, Baca QJ, Golan DE. Protein therapeutics: a summary and pharmacological classification. Nat. Rev. Drug Disc. 7(1), 21–39 (2008).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 11 Carpenter JF, Randolph TW, Jiskoot W, Crommelin DJ, Middaugh CR, Winter G. Potential inaccurate quantitation and sizing of protein aggregates by size exclusion chromatography: Essential need to use orthogonal methods to assure the quality of therapeutic protein products. J. Pharm. Sci. 99(5), 2200–2208 (2010).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 12 Ng R. Drugs: From Discovery to Approval. John Wiley & Sons, Inc., NJ, USA (2009).
  Google Scholar
• 13 Printz M, Friess W. Simultaneous detection and analysis of protein aggregation and protein unfolding by size exclusion chromatography with post column addition of the fluorescent dye BisANS. J. Pharm. Sci. 101(2), 826–837 (2012).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 14 Vazquez-Rey M, Lang DA. Aggregates in monoclonal antibody manufacturing processes. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 108(7), 1494–1508 (2011).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 15 Amin S, Barnett GV, Pathak JA, Roberts CJ, Sarangapani PS. Protein aggregation, particle formation, characterization & rheology. Curr. Opin. Colloid Interface Sci. 19(5), 438–449 (2014).
  CASGoogle Scholar
• 16 Gregoire S, Irwin J, Kwon I. Techniques for monitoring protein misfolding and aggregation in vitro and in living cells. Korean J. Chem. Eng. 29(6), 693–702 (2012).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 17 Narhi LO, Schmit J, Bechtold-Peters K, Sharma D. Classification of protein aggregates. J. Pharm. Sci. 101(2), 493–498 (2012).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 18 Philo JS. A critical review of methods for size characterization of non-particulate protein aggregates. Curr. Pharm. Biotechnol. 10(4), 359–372 (2009).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 19 den Engelsman J, Garidel P, Smulders R et al. Strategies for the assessment of protein aggregates in pharmaceutical biotech product development. Pharm. Res. 28(4), 920–933 (2011).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 20 Pryor NE, Moss MA, Hestekin CN. Unraveling the early events of amyloid-β protein (Aβ) aggregation: Techniques for the determination of Aβ aggregate size. Int. J. Mol. Sci. 13(3), 3038–3072 (2012).
  MedlineGoogle Scholar
• 21 Villari V, Micali N. Light scattering as spectroscopic tool for the study of disperse systems useful in pharmaceutical science. J. Pharm. Sci. 97(5), 1703–1730 (2008).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 22 Couteau O, Charoud-Got J, Rauscher H et al. A colloidal silica reference material for nanoparticle sizing by means of dynamic light scattering and centrifugal liquid sedimentation. Part. Part. Syst. Charact. 27(3–4), 112–124 (2010).
  Google Scholar
• 23 Hauck TS, Anderson RE, Fischer HC, Newbigging S, Chan WC. In vivo quantum-dot toxicity assessment. Small 6(1), 138–144 (2010).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 24 Khlebtsov BN, Khlebtsov NG. On the measurement of gold nanoparticle sizes by the dynamic light scattering Method. Colloid J. 73(1), 118–127 (2011).
  CASGoogle Scholar
• 25 Linegar KL, Adeniran AE, Kostko AF, Anisimov MA. Hydrodynamic radius of polyethylene glycol in solution obtained by dynamic light scattering. Colloid J. 72(2), 279–281 (2010).
  CASGoogle Scholar
• 26 Navarro FP, Berger M, Guillermet S et al. Lipid nanoparticle vectorization of indocyanine green improves fluorescence imaging for tumor diagnosis and lymph node resection. J. Biomed. Nanotechnol. 8(5), 730–741 (2012).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 27 Berne BJ, Pecora R. Dynamic Light Scattering: With Applications to Chemistry, Biology, and Physics. Wiley-Interscience, New York, NY, USA (1976).
  Google Scholar
• 28 Kato H, Suzuki M, Fujita K et al. Reliable size determination of nanoparticles using dynamic light scattering method for in vitro toxicology assessment. Toxicol. In Vitro 23(5), 927–934 (2009).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 29 Podzimek S. Light Scattering, Size Exclusion Chromatography, and Asymmetric Flow Field Flow Fractionation: Powerful Tools for the Characterization of Polymers, Proteins, and Nanoparticles. John Wiley, Hoboken, NJ, USA (2011).
  Google Scholar
• 30 Hassan PA, Rana S, Verma G. Making sense of brownian motion: colloid characterization by dynamic light scattering. Langmuir 31(1), 3–12 (2015). •• Gives a comprehensive overview for dynamic light scattering (theory and application).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 31 Lorber B, Fischer F, Bailly M, Roy H, Kern D. Protein analysis by dynamic light scattering: methods and techniques for students. Biochem. Mol. Biol. Edu. 40(6), 372–382 (2012).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 32 Achuthan S, Chung BJ, Ghosh P, Rangachari V, Vaidya A. A modified Stokes–Einstein equation for Abeta aggregation. BMC Bioinform. 12, S13 (2011).
  MedlineGoogle Scholar
• 33 Whittaker AG, Mount AR, Heal MR. Instant Notes in Physical Chemistry. Bios Scientific Publishers, Milton Park, UK (2000).
  Google Scholar
• 34 Lotya M, Rakovich A, Donegan JF, Coleman JN. Measuring the lateral size of liquid-exfoliated nanosheets with dynamic light scattering. Nanotechnology 24(26), 265703 (2013).
  MedlineGoogle Scholar
• 35 Drenski MF, Brader ML, Alston RW, Reed WF. Monitoring protein aggregation kinetics with simultaneous multiple sample light scattering. Anal. Biochem. 437(2), 185–197 (2013).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 36 Uversky VN. The mysterious unfoldome: structureless, underappreciated, yet vital part of any given proteome. J. Biomed. Biotechnol. 2010, 568068 (2010).
  MedlineGoogle Scholar
• 37 Uversky VN, Longhi S. Instrumental Analysis Of Intrinsically Disordered Proteins: Assessing Structure And Conformation. John Wiley & Sons, Hoboken, NJ, USA (2010).
  Google Scholar
• 38 Gast K, Fiedler C. Dynamic and static light scattering of intrinsically disordered proteins. Methods Mol. Biol. 896, 137–161 (2012).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 39 McPherson A, Gavira JA. Introduction to protein crystallization. Acta Crystallogr. F. Struct. Biol. Commun. 70, 2–20 (2014).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 40 Proteau A, Shi R, Cygler M. Application of dynamic light scattering in protein crystallization. Curr. Protoc. Protein Sci. 17(17), 10 (2010).
  MedlineGoogle Scholar
• 41 He F, Becker GW, Litowski JR, Narhi LO, Brems DN, Razinkov VI. High-throughput dynamic light scattering method for measuring viscosity of concentrated protein solutions. Anal. Biochem. 399(1), 141–143 (2010).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 42 Hackley VA, Cloqston JD. Measuring the hydrodynamic size of nanoparticles in aqueous media using batch-mode dynamic light scattering. Methods Mol. Biol. 697, 35–52 (2011).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 43 Takeuchi K, Nakatani Y, Hisatomi O. Accuracy of protein size estimates based on light scattering measurements. Open J. Biophys. 4, 83–91 (2014).
  Google Scholar
• 44 Galush WJ, Le LN, Moore JM. Viscosity behavior of high-concentration protein mixtures. J. Pharm. Sci. 101(3), 1012–1020 (2012).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 45 Yu Z, Reid JC, Yang YP. Utilizing dynamic light scattering as a process analytical technology for protein folding and aggregation monitoring in vaccine manufacturing. J. Pharm. Sci. 102(12), 4284–4290 (2013). •• Is a good example of using dynamic light scattering for protein aggregation studies.
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 46 Tomar AK, Sooch BS, Singh S, Yadav S. Aggregation analysis of Con A binding proteins of human seminal plasma: a dynamic light scattering study. Int. J. Biol. Macromol. 53, 133–137 (2013).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 47 Zhou C, Qi W, Lewis EN, Carpenter JF. Concomitant Raman spectroscopy and dynamic light scattering for characterization of therapeutic proteins at high concentrations. Anal. Biochem. 472, 7–20 (2015).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 48 Lewis EN, Qi W, Kidder LH, Amin S, Kenyon SM, Blake S. Combined dynamic light scattering and Raman spectroscopy approach for characterizing the aggregation of therapeutic proteins. Molecules 19(12), 20888–20905 (2014).
  MedlineGoogle Scholar
• 49 Streets AM, Sourigues Y, Kopito RR, Melki R, Quake SR. Simultaneous measurement of amyloid fibril formation by dynamic light scattering and fluorescence reveals complex aggregation kinetics. PLoS ONE 8(1), e54541 (2013).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 50 Filipe V, Hawe A, Jiskoot W. Critical evaluation of Nanoparticle Tracking Analysis (NTA) by NanoSight for the measurement of nanoparticles and protein aggregates. Pharm. Res. 27(5), 796–810 (2010).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 51 Striegel AM, Yau WW, Kirkland JJ, Bly DD. Modern Size-Exclusion Liquid Chromatography: Practice Of Gel Permeation And Gel Filtration Chromatography, (2nd Edition). John Wiley & Sons, Hoboken, NJ, USA (2009).
  Google Scholar
• 52 Sullivan MA, Powell PO, Witt T, Vilaplana F, Roura E, Gilbert RG. Improving size-exclusion chromatography separation for glycogen. J. Chromatogr. A 1332, 21–29 (2014).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 53 Gaborieau M, Castignolles P. Size-exclusion chromatography (SEC) of branched polymers and polysaccharides. Anal. Bioanal. Chem. 399(4), 1413–1423 (2011).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 54 Sakai-Kato K, Ota S, Hyodo K, Ishihara H, Kikuchi H, Kawanishi T. Size separation and size determination of liposomes. J. Sep. Sci. 34(20), 2861–2865 (2011).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 55 Zhang JT, Haas RM, Leone AM. Polydispersity characterization of lipid nanoparticles for siRNA delivery using multiple detection size-exclusion chromatography. Anal. Chem. 84(14), 6088–6096 (2012).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 56 Patil SV, Patil RY, Barge VU. Size-exclusion chromatography in biotech industry. J. Microbiol. Biotechnol. 3(4), 34545 (2014).
  Google Scholar
• 57 Kang DY, Moon JM, Lee S. Comparison of size-exclusion chromatography and flow field-flow fractionation for separation of whey proteins. Bull. Korean Chem. Soc. 32(4), 1315–1320 (2011).
  CASGoogle Scholar
• 58 Fekete S, Beck A, Veuthey JL, Guillarme D. Theory and practice of size exclusion chromatography for the analysis of protein aggregates. J. Pharm. Biomed. Anal. 101, 161–173 (2014).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 59 Arakawa T, Ejima D, Li T, Philo JS. The critical role of mobile phase composition in size exclusion chromatography of protein pharmaceuticals. J. Pharm. Sci. 99(4), 1674–1692 (2010).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 60 Hong P, Koza S, Bouvier ESP. Size-exclusion chromatography for the analysis of protein biotherapeutics and their aggregates. J. Liq. Chromatogr. Relat. Technol. 35(20), 2923–2950 (2012). • Evaluates the use of size-exclusion chromatography in more detail for studying protein aggregation.
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 61 Barnard JG, Singh S, Randolph TW, Carpenter JF. Subvisible particle counting provides a sensitive method of detecting and quantifying aggregation of monoclonal antibody caused by freeze-thawing: insights into the roles of particles in the protein aggregation pathway. J. Pharm. Sci. 100(2), 492–503 (2011).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 62 Fekete S, Katalin G, Davy G. Critical evaluation of fast size exclusion chromatographic separations of protein aggregates, applying sub-2 μm particles. J. Pharmaceut. Biomed. 78–79, 141–149 (2013).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 63 Muneeruddin K, Thomas JJ, Salinas PA, Kaltashov IA. Characterization of small protein aggregates and oligomers using size exclusion chromatography with online detection by native electrospray ionization mass spectrometry. Anal. Chem. 86(21), 10692–10699 (2014).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 64 Voynov V, Caravella JA. Therapeutic Proteins Methods and Protocols: Methods in Molecular Biology. Springer, Berlin, Germany (2012).
  Google Scholar
• 65 Grubisic Z, Rempp P, Benoit H. A universal calibration for gel permeation chromatography. J. Polym. Sci. Part C Polymer Lett. 5(9), 753–759 (1967).
  Google Scholar
• 66 Sung JJ, Pardeshi NN, Mulder AM et al. Transmission electron microscopy as an orthogonal method to characterize protein aggregates. J. Pharm. Sci. 104, 750–759 (2014).
  MedlineGoogle Scholar
• 67 Muller-Reichart T, Verkade P. Correlative Light And Electron Microscopy. Academic Press, Elsevier, Amsterdam, The Netherlands (2014).
  Google Scholar
• 68 Shindo D, Oikawa T. Analytical Electron Microscopy For Materials Science. Springer, Berlin, Germany, 152 (2002).
  Google Scholar
• 69 Egerton RF. Physical Principles of Electron Microscopy: An Introduction to TEM SEM and AEM. Springer, Berlin, Germany, 211 (2008).
  Google Scholar
• 70 Webb W, Anderson VL. Transmission electron microscopy characterization of fluorescently labelled amyloid β 1–40 and α-synuclein aggregates. BMC Biotechnol. 11, 125 (2011).
  MedlineGoogle Scholar
• 71 Cosslett VE. Radiation damage in the high resolution electron microscopy of biological materials: a review. J. Microsc. 113(2), 113–129 (1978).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 72 Zhang L, Song J, Cavigiolio G et al. Morphology and structure of lipoproteins revealed by an optimized negative-staining protocol of electron microscopy. J. Lipid Res. 52(1), 175–184 (2011).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 73 Khudyakov Y, Pumpens P. Viral Nanotechnology. CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL, USA (2016).
  Google Scholar
• 74 Bartesaghi A, Matthies D, Banerjee S, Merk A, Subramaniam S. Structure of β-galactosidase at 3.2-Å resolution obtained by cryo-electron microscopy. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci USA 111(32), 11709–11714 (2014).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 75 Wendler P, Saibil HR. Cryo electron microscopy structures of Hsp100 proteins: crowbars in or out? Biochem. Cell Biol. 88(1), 89–96 (2010).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 76 Zhao G, Perilla JR, Yufenyuy EL et al. Mature HIV-1 capsid structure by cryo-electron microscopy and all-atom molecular dynamics. Nature 497, 643–646 (2013).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 77 Kuntsche J, Horst JC, Bunjes H. Cryogenic transmission electron microscopy (cryo-TEM) for studying the morphology of colloidal drug delivery systems. Int. J. Pharm. 417(1–2), 120–137 (2011).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 78 Fox CB, Mulligan SK, Sung J et al. Cryogenic transmission electron microscopy of recombinant tuberculosis vaccine antigen with anionic liposomes reveals formation of flattened liposomes. Int. J. Nanomedicine 9, 1367–1377 (2014).
  MedlineGoogle Scholar
• 79 Wilson SM, Bacic A. Preparation of plant cells for transmission electron microscopy to optimize immunogold labeling of carbohydrate and protein epitopes. Nat. Protoc. 7(9), 1716–1727 (2012).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 80 Aris R. On the dispersion of a solute in a fluid flowing through a tube. Proc. R. Soc. A 235, 67–77 (1956).
  Google Scholar
• 81 Taylor G. Dispersion of soluble matter in solvent flowing slowly through a tube. Proc. R. Soc. A 219, 186–203 (1953).
  CASGoogle Scholar
• 82 Cipelletti L, Biron JP, Martin M, Cottet H. Polydispersity analysis of Taylor dispersion data: the cumulant method. Anal. Chem. 86(13), 6471–6478 (2014).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 83 Hulse W, Forbes R. A Taylor dispersion analysis method for the sizing of therapeutic proteins and their aggregates using nanolitre sample quantities. Int. J. Pharm. 416(1), 394–397 (2011).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 84 Franzen U, Vermehren C, Jensen H, Østergaard J. Physicochemical characterization of a PEGylated liposomal drug formulation using capillary electrophoresis. Electrophoresis 32, 738–748 (2011).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 85 Cottet H, Biron JP, Cipelletti L, Matmour R, Martin M. Determination of individual diffusion coefficients in evolving binary mixtures by taylor dispersion analysis: application to the monitoring of polymer reaction. Anal. Chem. 82(5), 1793–1802 (2010). •• Covers Taylor dispersion data (TDA) theory and its application for mixtures. Very good paper for learning how to use TDA technique.
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 86 Hulse WL, Forbes RT. A nanolitre method to determine the hydrodynamic radius of proteins and small molecules by Taylor dispersion analysis. Int. J. Pharm. 411(1–2), 64–68 (2011).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 87 Kok WT, Tudos AJ, Grutters M, Shepherd AG. Characterization of asphaltenes by nonaqueous capillary electrophoresis. Energy Fuels 25(1), 208–214 (2011).
  CASGoogle Scholar
• 88 Lewandrowska A, Majcher A, Ochab-Marcinek A, Tabaka M, Holyst R. Taylor dispersion analysis in coiled capillaries at high flow rates. Anal. Chem. 85(8), 4051–4056 (2013).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 89 Ibrahim A, Meyrueix R, Pouliquen G, Chan YP, Cottet H. Size and charge characterization of polymeric drug delivery systems by Taylor dispersion analysis and capillary electrophoresis. Anal. Bioanal. Chem. 405(16), 5369–5379 (2013). • Gives example of diverse application of TDA.
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 90 Cottet H, Biron JP, Martin M. Taylor dispersion analysis of mixtures. Anal. Chem. 79, 9066–9073 (2007).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 91 Cottet H, Martin M, Papillaud A, Souaid E, Collet H, Commeyras A. Determination of dendrigraft poly-L-lysine diffusion coefficinets by taylor dispersion analysis. Biomacromolecules 8(10). 3235–3243 (2007).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 92 Oukacine F, Morel A, Desvignes I, Cottet H. Size-based characterization of nanoparticle mixtures by the inline coupling of capillary electrophoresis to Taylor dispersion analysis. J. Chromatogr. A 1426, 220–225 (2015).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 93 Ye FB, Jensen H, Larsen SW, Yaghmur A, Larsen C, Ostergaard J. Measurement of drug diffusivities in pharmaceutical solvents using Taylor dispersion analysis. J. Pharm. Biomed. 61, 176–183 (2012).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 94 Hulse WL, Gray J, Forbes RT. Evaluating the inter and intra batch variability of protein aggregation behaviour using Taylor dispersion analysis and dynamic light scattering. Int. J. Pharm. 453(2), 351–357 (2013).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 95 Jensen SS, Jensen H, Cornett C, Moller EH, Ostergaard J. Insulin diffusion and self-association characterized by real-time UV imaging and Taylor dispersion analysis. J. Pharm. Biomed. 92, 203–210 (2014).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 96 Liechty WB, Kryscio DR, Slaughter BV, Peppas NA. Polymers for drug delivery systems. Annu. Rev. Chem. Biom. Eng. 1, 149–173 (2010).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 97 Oukacine F, Bernard S, Bobe I, Cottet H. Physico-chemical characterization of polymeric micelles loaded with platinum derivatives by capillary electrophoresis and related methods. J. Control. Release 196, 139–145 (2014).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 98 Chamieh J, Davanier F, Jannin V, Demarne F, Cottet H. Size characterization of commercial micelles and microemulsions by Taylor dispersion analysis. Int. J. Pharm. 492, 46–54 (2015).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 99 Chamieh J, Jannin V, Demarne F, Cottet H. Hydrodynamic size characterization of a self-emulsifying lipid pharmaceutical excipient by Taylor dispersion analysis with fluorescent detection. Int. J. Pharm. 513, 262–269 (2016).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 100 Lavoisier A, Schlaeppi JM. Early developability screen of therapeutic antibody candidates using Taylor dispersion analysis and UV area imaging detection. MAbs 7(1), 77–83 (2015).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar
• 101 Cipelletti L, Biron JP, Martin M, Cottet H. Measuring arbitrary diffusion coefficient distributions of nano-objects by Taylor dispersion analysis. Anal. Chem. 87(16), 8489–8496 (2015).
  Medline CASGoogle Scholar